To me, the back story and lore would be more important than having a fun and challenging campaign (simply because there are already so many fun Sins maps, but no back story except for the little description of the map, the description of the sub faction  and what is found in the intro video and manual). But if it was possible to have both, by all means, both is better.

I would actually prefer if the campaign forced me to play one faction. I think that without this it wouldn't be much of a campaign, more of a scenario.

Concerning the having to play a modded version of Sins, I would prefer it if it was straight vanilla Sins Rebellion, but if you added something like a fortress world for, say, the Vasari's nemesis, and made it look lore-friendly, I would not object. But to add a faction out of the Sins universe, or to add more ships to the existing factions, well, I would rather not. But to add a unique ship that you have to escort, and made it faction-fitting, I think that would actually enhance the appeal of the campaign.

I think that a linear campaign would allow for a higher degree of quality, so I would shoot for that.

If you are actually volunteering to do this, Seleuceia, you are awesome. If you actually finish it, and it is amazing, as Sins deserves, then you are triple awesome. If you are trolling, well, suffice to say you are very far from awesome.

It would be an interesting project, but I find most are just extended tutorials to make you learn proper play. Forcing the colonization of 2 planets within a time would be 1st. Other multiplayer must knows should all be parts.

I know dev mode saves are in txt, I think reg mode saves are in bin, maybe possible to write a small app that reads values from 1 save and transfers lines of text values to the other save. Not sure about bin format though, would need to convert it I assume.

I would stay close to canon but maybe do pre story. A TEC shipping captian on a Cap ship that has no guns or hangars, use a couple old beta ships maybe. As the story progresses, add guns and more guns and abilities to the captains ship. Make the pre-story whatever you like but get to the point of a canon 10 player skirmish.

Could add another race maybe, have the Vasari whipe them out b4 reaching you, then the race is playable in skirmish.

Campaign would be fun. More lore content would be good, with more sins art. It would be fun to have scenarios where your place are determined by your faction, and should achieve something, not just skirmishing everytime.

Tutorials are very weak, they only teach you so few things... you barely get a real look on things and even many basic things are not mentioned there. Not to speak about efficient play, noobs get to clue about it from the tutorials.

Using a mod for getting campaign? I would rather be pleased if the campaign was with the original game, as many mods ruin some basic things, this way becoming unenjoyable for me.

I am serious, but not serious....if that makes any sense.....

My schedule allows me to work on SoaSE stuff only in small bursts, so I do what I can...

My current thought right now is that the only way to do a campaign is to use save files....unfortunately, that means that every updated could potentially break those saves...obviously you can see why one might not be so inclined to do such a thing if there isn't even much demand and it could come under heavy criticism and it may become obsolete in the near future...

I'm taking the wait and see approach....my current plan is to finish my personal mod, release it, and then make a campaign off of that...I would consider doing a special version for vanilla Sins if there was demand, but the vanilla gameplay is very unappealing to me so I have mixed feelings about dedicating my time to a vanilla campaign...

I do have a decent Lore/Story developed in my head that would lay out as a campaign following three "stories", one for each of the races (Sins of the Traders, Sins of the Seraphs, and Sins of the Empire)...however, I also may have it so that each of the 9 races (pre-rebellion, loyalist, and rebel faction for each of the 3 races) is played at least once, with the player simply changing which "side" they are between "missions"...

So for example, you may play as Vasari and rush to wipe out x number of trader planets in a certain amount of time, but in the next mission play as TEC and have to research a "victory technology" (perhaps it represents "forming the coalition") before losing too many more planets...

Yup, and a few players have made maps like that, though before Rebellion.

@Seleu Can you stop talking about it and do it already! Im sure there will be a ton of interest and help offered once its off the block. I will even test play through your campaign free of charge!

Why are you here?

For those interested, the mod I want to release is slowly in progress...once it is completed, I will consider using a series of saved games to do a campaign...