Fianlly figured it out, You were right about the problem but the issue was that "Local Settings" is just an old junction point that doesn't really exist any longer so I couldn't get into that folder. There was a galaxy file in:
C:\Users\[user]\AppData\Local\Ironclad Games\Sins of a Solar Empire\Galaxy
Oddly enough, it was last modified the day I installed 1.14 which to my knowledge I've never created any. In any case, I cleared the file from that path and everything is fine now. That location also has all the old save files that don't work any longer so I took care of those too.
Thanks for the help, much appreciated!